Anya Kamenetz asks "Who's American Dream is it Anyway?"

Silly me. While I’ve been focusing on how the music industry seems hell-bent on its own self-destruction, Anya Kamenetz has been looking a far larger picture: the whole American way of life. And I think she has a point.

My complaints about the mainstream music industry have been twofold:

  1. Live venues that have mutated from intimate experiences that connected artists and audiences to arenas, with terrible acoustics, dangerous volume levels, and the sale of large quantities of alcohol to dull the senses and numb the brain.
  2. Recorded products that suffer from poor production values, particularly excessive loudness, and which are wrapped so thickly in plastic and legal accusations that consumers are looking elsewhere to spend their dollars.

And so while I look at how to build an environment where both the performance of music and the production of music can thrive, Anya comes along and says the whole system is about to change, and maybe sooner rather than later.

For me, the most encouraging insight is the section she writes about “Time, not Stuff”. It’s a theme I’ve written about before. Now, one can take the optimistic view, as Robert Frank did in his piece Experience is the New Luxury, or the realistic view that Anya Kamenetz takes, where she says:

As we weather this economic downturn, I predict that even more young people are going to choose — or be pushed into — a smaller-scale, downshifted lifestyle where they make do with less stuff and trade more money for more time.

People are already planting more gardens, driving less and riding their bikes or public transportation more, canceling their cable subscriptions, and spending more time at home. This is a perfect example of making a virtue out of necessity — all these changes save money, but they also mean a slower, healthier lifestyle that for some is its own reward.

Indeed, the freedom to choose what one does with their time is one definition of luxury, one that does not require millions of dollars to realize. As she also points out

Once a nation has a per capita income above $12,000, for example, there is little correlation between wealth and happiness.

And in the U.S., researcher Daniel Gilbert found, once an individual passes $50,000 a year in income, more money has little effect on his or her happiness on average.

That’s not to say that all forms of luxury are available to any who wish for it, but if people are intentional about what they want, and what they want is to share and experience the resources of the community, maybe musicians will find that they get a better deal from a downshifted lifestyle to one that’s so focused on excessive and conspicuous consumption.

Comments from Detroit suggest that car buying habits have changed, perhaps permanently. Whereas previously consumers were thrilled to wrap themselves in 2 tons of steel to drive to the corner coffee shop, now we are walking, experiencing our neighborhoods instead of barreling through them. And as we downsize our cars to a sensible level, where could we spend the money we’re not squandering on gas and raw tonnage? On authentic experiences meaningful to us, of course!

1 thought on “Anya Kamenetz asks "Who's American Dream is it Anyway?"”

  1. I completely agree that all consumer habits are changing and it is ultimately for the better! When gas started getting more expensive, I got on a bike for the first time in 10 years and I was instantly hooked. No gas worries, no parking worries and I’m getting more of a workout than just pushing my foot down on my gas guzzling 4 runner. The beauty of it all is that you become so much more involved and aware of what is going on and what exists in your neighborhood. I’ve found all sorts of cool boutiques, thrift stores, GREAT restaurants…It’s crazy. When you are driving you don’t stop and mill around, you just go from point A to B with tunnel vision. Have you read The 4 Hour Work Week? It is a cornerstone of the principal of ‘making more time to do what you want.’ I think (and hope) that the new American Dream is to have more time to do what you really want. Sure, maybe you won’t be as rich but I really do think that you will be more fulfilled. We’ll spend more time enjoying life than working towards a retirement we probably can’t enjoy because we’re too exhausted.
    Michael- First off, I might be wrong, but I believe we have a mutual friend, Calvin Matthews? Secondly, that is completely off point but back to what I’m getting at…I have full faith that the music industry will do a turn around as well. Eventually people will get sick of the insane prices for tickets and the hoopla will calm and we will return to music. It’s all about the music. I remember when Dave Matthews ‘sold out’, trading venues like Red Rocks to perform at The Pepsi Center. Arg. I personally am welcoming this ‘new American Dream’. As the marketing director for the American Association of Young People, it’s articles like Anya’s and your’s that motivate me to spread the good word to my fellow youngins’. We have the power to shape the road ahead and if we are moving towards a dream where less money means more quality time… I’ll gladly sacrifice my 4 Runner and expensive habits.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s